Monday Morning Quarterback — Pens and Inks Version

football

American football kicked off its season this week, just in time to inspire this post. Since the NFL has traditionally played its games on Sunday, we call post-game insights and criticisms “Monday morning quarterbacking.” After all, hindsight is always 20/20. But that can be helpful, too. So maybe it will be useful to look back at my pens and inks last week with a little hindsight.

1. Luckiest guess. Putting Diamine’s Shimmertastic Brandy Dazzle into a Pelikan Ibis with broad nib. The vintage Pelikan has a lot of ink flow, and the nib has a bit of flex, and both those characteristics really showed what Brandy Dazzle could do.

2. Luckiest break. I am very lucky to have a great friend who sent me six Shimmertastic ink samples to play with. They were all such fun.

3. Undeserved criticism award. Diamine took a lot of internet heat for putting the name “Shimmertastic” on its forthcoming ink line. And, yes, “Shimmer” would have been fine. But the truth is, after you use the word “Shimmertastic” a few times, you kind of forget that it sounds silly and just go with it. Heck, the inks do shimmer. And they are sort of fantastic. The power of suggestion worked for me here.

4. Deserved criticism award. Pelikan took a lot of internet heat for its M600 Pink Pelikan box design. And maybe Pelikan should have listened. Though it turns out I liked untying the bow, I think just a bow would have been quite enough to set the box apart. The corset lace design felt a little “ick” to me. And even if you like it, it does seem out-of-step with what is actually a fairly classy and professional pen.

5. Unluckiest break. In 2005, the Chicago Bears had the fourth pick in the NFL draft, which they wasted on a running back whose ignominious Bears career would be over by 2008. Among the players the Bears passed over was Aaron Rodgers, the quarterback of my beloved University of California Golden Bears. Worse, Rodgers was drafted by none other than the Green Bay Packers, arch-rivals of the Bears. Rodgers has gone on to become probably the best quarterback in football, a fact that he demonstrates to Chicago fans twice a year by stomping on our Bears. As he did once again yesterday. Sigh.

Pen of the Day: Sailor Desk Pen

DSC_2862

Sailor Desk Pen. This is another sub-$15 plastic desk pen featuring an ultra-fine Japanese nib.  I’ve got it filled with Sailor’s pigment-based ink, the nano ink Kiwa-guro.  The combination is very similar to the Platinum Carbon Desk Pen featured Tuesday.

DSC_2868

Sailor’s stainless steel nib is marked extra-fine.  I find it very similar in width to both the Platinum desk pen with Carbon Black and the Pilot Prera fine nib with Pilot Black (a regular dye-based ink).  The two desk pens may write slightly thinner lines than the Prera with fine nib, but all three are pretty close in my real world use.

Sailor Kiwa-guro ink is made from pigments rather than dye, so it’s similar to Platinum Carbon ink.  In the desk pens, Kiwa-guro is darker and blacker than Platinum Carbon ink.  However, Kiwa-guro is only water-resistant, while Platinum Carbon ink is totally waterproof.

DSC_2864

Pen of the Day: Platinum Carbon Desk Pen

DSC_2846

Platinum Carbon Desk Pen. This is an inexpensive plastic desk pen made by Platinum for its Carbon Black ink. I bought this, and a similar desk pen made by Sailor, years ago for drawing. I decided to take them out again this week for writing.

DSC_2858

The Platinum desk pen has a nice, smooth nib, and I like the pen’s light weight, long length and good balance.  It can take a Platinum converter if you want to use bottled ink. It’s a good pen to write with, for me.  Platinum describes the nib as “super fine.” It may be slightly thinner than my Pilot Prera fine nib with Pilot black ink, but I really think the two are comparable.

Platinum Carbon ink is marked safe for fountain pens, but I have had some difficulties with pigment inks over the years, so I honestly prefer to use them in dedicated cheaper pens, like this one.  Carbon Black is a waterproof and lightproof pigment-based ink.  It’s reputed to be a very dark black ink, but in this pen I don’t get that.  It writes smoothly and dries quickly. This combination easily could be an everyday user.

DSC_2850

J. Herbin Emerald of Chivor: The Cleanup

DSC_2427

I liked this ink so much, I ended up buying a full bottle. But until recently I couldn’t really test how it cleaned up from a pen — I was too happy using it to empty the pen.

On August 24, I filled my Pelikan M600 with Emerald of Chivor. By the night of September 5, it was time to clean out the pen. It had been left filled for 12 days, which is a fairly long time for me. There are a few conventional inks I wouldn’t keep in a pen that long.

(click Page 2 below to continue)