House Rules: Ethics

Caran d'Ache Chromatics ink bottles in box

Usually, I am talking about things that I have already purchased with my own money.

Sometimes I get pens on loan from the manufacturer or from a friend. When that happens, I say so.

Sometimes I get inks to review from the manufacturer. When that happens, I say so.

Sometimes I get ink from a friend. I usually say so, to thank them. Sometimes I don’t, because I’ve forgotten, or because it feels like overkill, or even bragging, the fifth time you mention getting a gift from a friend.

In no case does how I obtained an item influence what I think about it.

However, it may matter to you. Which is why I disclose if I received an ink (or the loan of a pen) from a manufacturer. But at the risk of repeating myself, just because I disclose that I received an ink sample (or the loan of a pen) doesn’t mean that it has influenced my opinion.

It has not.

In no case have I ever liked something more because it was free, nor have I ever given a “better” review in exchange for something free. Nor have I ever pulled any punches because something was given free, or because I somehow worried that I wouldn’t get more free samples. I’ve never done that. And I never would.

Let me explain why.

1. I am an honest person. Of the values I consider most important, honestly and integrity are in the top three.

2. It’s an ink sample. Or a loaned pen. I don’t think I can be bought, but I am perfectly sure I can’t be bought at that price.

Further, I’ve never had a manufacturer ask me for anything in exchange for an ink or the loan of a pen. Nor have they ever expressed displeasure with anything I’ve ever said. There’s not some deep conspiracy out there, at least not one that reaches my little blog.

And I will keep it that way, thank you.

Those are my ethics.

There’s one more “rule” here at Fountain Pen Follies, I guess, besides honesty and disclosure. And that traces back to the third thing I value very highly. Though I don’t always observe this unfailingly in my daily life, I try for it always. And that is kindness.

As one aspect of that, I prefer to look at people (and things) in the best possible light. Not the worst.

So I do not enjoy trashing people or products in public or slinging nasty words. I’m not the person who’s going to post that a particular ink or pen is “ugly.” Even though those posts are the most popular. I don’t do that because I don’t find that helpful. Also because I figure your taste probably is different than mine. And I love that. We don’t learn as much from people we already agree with.

But though I don’t like to trash things, I will certainly say if something I’ve used has shown an issue. For example, if  I found an ink hard to clean, or if I saw little creatures growing in a different ink.

Those two inks happened to be made two of my favorite brands. The first is even made by a brand that has given me some free ink samples. And the second, the ink that had the mold, well that’s a funny thing, because it subsequently turned out that I was not the first person to notice it. But I was the first person who went on two fountain pen forums, in addition to this blog, and warned others. And some fans of the brand didn’t take that well.

But those are my ethics.

And here’s another funny thing: the manufacturer ended up thanking me for telling them about the problem. People should consider that some companies actually want to hear honest opinions, because it helps them improve their products and know what customers are thinking.

There’s one more thing I should mention. I spend a lot of time on my reviews. With an ink, I like to use it over a few weeks. I take care that the photos are accurate and color-balanced, so the ink onscreen looks like the ink in real life. I don’t do a review hastily, and I don’t do it heedlessly. But nor do I do it because it’s profitable or I want free stuff. If you consider the value of your time, you definitely wouldn’t find it profitable to spend hours with a $2 ink sample. Or a loaned pen, for that matter.

I take care with my reviews because I want to do a good job. Because other people’s reviews and photos have been helpful to me, and I hope some of mine may be helpful to others.

Those are my ethics.

8 thoughts on “House Rules: Ethics

  1. Hi Laura
    Don’t worry about those people on the forum some of them should learn to engage their brains before putting there mouths in drive. I like your reviews and I am sure there are many others who do too. Your sense of humour shows and so does your positive nature.
    I also like Chrissy’s reviews on fpgeeks which are a little more formal but also in a positive way.
    Anyway keep up the good work.
    Michael

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Anyone who complains that ink reviews are inherently useless has either been reading the wrong kind, or reading the right kind of review in the wrong way. Like anything else, you have to know what you’re looking for, what traits matter to you, and look for info on those while accepting – gasp! – that not all reviews are going to cover what YOU care about.

    Besides, I agree with Nadine, who on earth wants the whole tedious pretense of ‘objectivity’ in a review. That’s why you read it: you want the person’s opinion! There’s a gaping chasm between this kind of natural bias, which is a viewpoint, and the outright dishonesty these people seem to see everywhere. Telling the two apart’s what separates the men from the boys: blanket cynicism is as easy as wide-eyed naivety.

    For my part I can say I’ve learned a ton from your reviews about inks – and I’ve been writing with FPs my whole life. You keep doing you, it’s working great!

    Liked by 3 people

  3. Your ethics seem pretty sound to me. When it comes to pens, ink etc. it’s hard to be entirely objective in a review (we all have different tastes and preferences). Any effort to ‘standardise’ reviewing risks taking away the emotional element of why we like and use fountain pens. Keep up the good work.

    Illegitimi non carborundum!

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Your ethics show in your posts and anyone saying something different didn’t read them fully, if you ask me. But you’ll always get people like that, even if you don’t accept gifts or whatever… and that they aren’t objective… I have to agree, they aren’t. That’s kind of the point for me. But the pictures are – and you make amazing pictures! So I understand. Don’t let yourself be drawn down by this!
    And thank you for your amazing reviews. They have helped me several times!

    Liked by 2 people

  5. They are indeed! And well said. I had wondered if that discussion hid some other agenda, but I guess I’ll never know. The point about reputations though is worth considering. When one garners a reputation as a ‘voice’ in the hobby (any aspect: pens, nibs, paper etc.) then readers are likely to act upon that. Is this a responsibility that is thrust upon the reviewer by the reader? And does the reviewer have to acknowledge it? Tricky questions, and I don’t have answers. 🙂

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.