Ink Review: KWZ Iron Gall Orange

KWZ Iron Gall Orange writing sample

I’m used to KWZ inks varying from their names sometimes — that’s part of the charm of this inventive and interesting ink company. Thus KWZ Dark Brown is so dark a brown as to be, in effect, a light black, and KWZ Brown-Pink manages to look brown pink, but also kind of purple.

However, KWZ Iron Gall Orange is even more mind-bending: it never really looks orange.  Perhaps that’s because of the iron gall component, which often affects an ink’s color. Iron gall also provides water resistance. And it can make an ink higher maintenance. However, I’ve used iron gall inks for years, and I love them for the shading and how well they do on poor paper.

I used KWZ Iron Gall Orange for three weeks in a Kaweco Classic Sport with broad nib, and in a Lamy Safari with fine nib, both converter pens. Here is a writing sample on white Rhodia paper.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange writing sample

And here is closer look.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange writing sample

Here is KWZ Iron Gall Orange from both pens on cream-color Tomoe River paper.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange writing sample

And here it is on my “regular paper,” Staples Sustainable Earth, to see how it looks on paper that isn’t fountain-pen friendly.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange writing sample

KWZ Iron Gall Orange behaves very well on poor paper, as iron gall inks tend to. I had no feathering, bleedthrough or showthrough on the Staples paper, even from the Kaweco with broad nib.

In the Kaweco Sport I saw no hesitation in startup or flow with the ink, even after it had been left unused for a week. After the same week off, the dry-writing Safari only needed to be turned nib-down for a bit; otherwise it was perfect.

As an iron gall ink, it’s not surprising that KWZ Iron Gall Orange has excellent water resistance on both regular paper and smooth Rhodia. The orange dye washes away to an extent, but a very legible line remains.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange water resistance

Now we get to the surprising part of KWZ Iron Gall Orange, at least for me. This is the first KWZ iron gall that I have tried that was challenging to clean from a pen.

Here is the converter of my Safari after more than three weeks filled with Iron Gall Orage. Some of the ink has slipped behind the piston.

ink converter

So, it’s a nicely lubricated ink, yes. But that’s not the kind of ink flow anyone wants to see, and I did have to disassemble the Safari converter to fully clean it. Now, possibly it’s a converter problem that has just developed, not an ink issue. And I’ve seen this in the past with other converters and other inks.

But here is the old-style squeeze converter of my Kaweco Sport after I had cleaned out KWZ Iron Gall Orange by flushing and soaking with water.

ink converter with residue

You can see some black residue that has clung to the plastic nose and to the sac. I could not remove that with soaking or flushing cycles.

I went to my high-tech secret weapon. The pipe cleaner.

pipe cleaner with ink residue

And little black bits came right out.

Now it’s all clean — that gray-looking ring just behind the metal is just clear water.

ink converter clean

I saw the same residue in the Safari converter in the area between the converter wall and the plastic opening. After I removed the plastic bit, that was easy to rub off with just a paper towel.

To me the extra cleanup required of KWZ Iron Gall Orange in these two converters does suggest caution when selecting a pen. I would choose a pen that gives easy access to whatever holds the ink, in case flushing and soaking isn’t enough. Actually, it was because the ink in the sample vial seemed a little dense that I chose two converter pens, and I am glad I did.

However, note that I had the pens filled for more than three weeks, and there was one week I didn’t write with them. That might have contributed to the buildup. Also, I only saw an issue with the converters; the ink seemed to flush out easily from the nibs and feeds, and the stainless steel nibs showed no effect. And after all it is a water-resistant ink, which often means more cleanup.

Other than that, what really stands out for me about KWZ Iron Gall Orange is the color. It has an unusual tint.

In some ways KWZ Iron Gall Orange reminds me of brass — but unpolished, aged brass. But it also seems vegetal — like something you would come across near a pond or swamp.

In terms of ink comparisons, my closest ink is J. Herbin Lie de Thé.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange and J. Herbin Lie de Thé swabs

Lie de Thé, while a golden brown of similar value, is browner. KWZ Iron Gall Orange has a muddier hue and a different tint.

Just for fun, here’s an orange ink next to KWZ Iron Gall Orange.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange and Caran d'Ache Electric Orange swabs

So, yeah. Not a classic orange, that KWZ Iron Gall Orange.

Well, finally, the paper towel chromatography for KWZ Iron Gall Orange.

KWZ Iron Gall Orange ink chromatography

So this really is complex ink. Also interesting, and unusual, right down to the chromatography. And I found the black stuff from the converter. That looks like it could just be dye.

KWZ Ink is available online from at least one US store and also directly from KWZ in Poland.  KWZ’s website contains excellent information about using and cleaning out iron gall inks.

4 thoughts on “Ink Review: KWZ Iron Gall Orange

  1. This looks a bit like Noodler’s Kiowa Pecan, which is one of the very few Noodler inks I liked. This is good because overall Noodler’s is a bit of a pain to get and so on, whereas KWZ should be easier (someday, when the capital controls ease). Plus it’s an iron gall, so it’s a little splash proof.

    On another note, omg I need pipe cleaners! I don’t know why it never occurred to me to have some on hand, but I can see from this post how useful they are. I will remedy this oversight immediately!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Lie de Thé is one of my favorite brown inks, in terms of color and also easy cleanup.

    With regard to iron gall inks. I think you have to do what’s right for you. I adore them myself, but I put them in pens that can handle them, and I use fairly gentle iron gall inks made for fountain pens. And I clean up the pen very carefully afterwards. Most modern iron gall inks are very gentle, but you need to test them first.

    This one, though, also by KWZ, is one of my favorite blue inks ever: https://fountainpenfollies.com/2016/01/07/ink-review-kwz-iron-gall-blue-5/ 🙂

    Like

  3. a really interesting ink color, but I think I’ll stick with the Lie de The suggestion 🙂 I’m still very vary when it comes to iron gall inks, in part due to what you warned of, in part due to all those warnings as to danger to the nib which I read online. (I also read that those were for vintage pens mostly, but I’m still wary 😛 )

    So I’ll refrain, for now, from using any iron gall ink. But it’s a real shame because as you also commented, they do have the most gorgeous shading sometimes. Decisions, decisions… 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.